Top 24 - Let's Break it Down...
BOYS vs. GIRLS
The girls win! I actually didn’t see this one coming. I really thought the boys had it, but it looks like the girls learned a lot from watching the guys the night before. They were able to see how the staging worked, how the judges reacted and how the audience reacted before ever stepping foot on the stage. It’s definitely a perk, and they took full advantage of it.
So, since we have to do rankings to play in Fantasy Idol, I thought I would briefly tell you what I thought of each performance this week. Let me know if you agree or disagree. I will start by saying, this is the hugest and saddest elimination ever! I can’t believe I have to pick only a Top 5 (maybe 6 or 7) boys and girls to make it through. It just doesn’t seem right, but here we go......To read Melinda's thoughts on each contestant go to HitFix.com and make sure to join Melinda's Fantasy Idol League while you're there!!
posted by Melinda Doolittle at
11:26 AM
1 Comments:
Melinda... I agree. I have had the same thoughts about missing Simon... a lot. I don't think the judges get it this year. Granted, the level of competition,the talent, is higher this year then in years past. But at the same time, no one has enormous talent, and all leave room for critisism.. they just don't often get any. Not really. And when they do it is always tempered with a "You know I love the way u sing" caveat Honestly tho, Melinda, I continue to watch AI but it is mostly from habit. I know their formula works for popular television, but it leaves a lot to be desired as a true talent search... leaving it to the 14 and 15y.o. kids. When u didn't win in your season, my enthusiasm for the show waned. I know u have heard this a million times... hahaha.... probably more... but AI has never had the talant before u or after u... that u displayed week after week... after week. I hope u r doing well dear lady... mostly I hope u have found a producer that is more interested in displaying your talent than he is in displaying his own. I haven't checked out your web page for some time but I am glad I did. The title of your new album interests me a lot and I will buy it. It sounds like something that will show case your voice. Thanks for reinforcing what I have been thinking about regards the critisism on AI... and good fortune.
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home